Holiday Shipping Deadlines:

Christmas: Orders Due No Later than Sunday December 16 at Noon. After that time, we cannot guarantee pies will arrive in time for the holiday.

In Store Pick-Up Order Deadlines:

Christmas: Order Cut Off is December 21st at Noon.

Nut Pies

Pecan

A Williamsburg tradition, our pecan pie is an 80 year old family recipe made from hand rolled dough and fancy mammoth pecan halves. This pecan pie is unique in that it is not lightly baked and overly sweet.

$13.00 + $10.00 S$H

Chocolate Pecan

The addition of semi-sweet chocolate chips gives our pecan pie a little extra sweetness, perfect for chocolate lovers.

$14.00 + $10.00 S$H

Butterscotch Pecan

Lately becoming a new favorite the addition of butterscotch morsels gives this pie a richness that is unique and delicious.

$14.00 + $10.00 S$H

Virginia Peanut & Chocolate Peanut

Virginia classics that we bake in the same manner as our pecan pies but substitute roasted, unsalted Virginia peanuts.

Peanut $13.00 + $10.00S$H

VA Chocolate Peanut $14.00+ $10.00 S$H

Hazelnut, Chocolate Hazelnut
& Cinnamon Raisin Hazelnut

Truly unique these pies will please those that appreciate the flavor and texture of quality hazelnuts.

Hazelnut $13.00+ $10.00 S$H

Chocolate Hazelnut $14.00+ $10.00 S$H

Cinnamon Raisin Hazelnut $14.00+ $10.00 S$H

Fruit Pies

Fruit Pies are Zip Code Sensetive!
JTP does not reccommend shipping fruit pies to zip codes west of the Mississippi.
If you're "out west" try a nut pie instead!

Strawberry, Strawberry Rhubarb
& Strawberry Peach

Wonderful summer pies for those that crave the natural sweetness of strawberries and peaches or the subtle tart flavor of rhubarb.

Strawberry $13.00+ $10.00 S$H

Strawberry Rhubarb $14.00+ $10.00 S$H

Strawberry Peach $14.00+ $10.00 S$H

Blueberry & Blueberry Peach

These pies are loaded with delicious and sweet local blueberries and topped with a lattice crust.

Blueberry $13.00+ $10.00 S$H

Blueberry Peach $14.00+ $10.00 S$H

Blackberry & Blackberry Peach

Fresh Virginia blackberries give these pies a wonderful texture and sweetness.

Blackbery $13.00+ $10.00 S$H

Blackberry Peach $14.00+ $10.00 S$H

Raspberry & Raspberry Peach

The mild tartness of red raspberries give these pies a flavor distinct from all our other fruit pies.

Raspberry $13.00+ $10.00 S$H

Raspberry Peach $14.00+ $10.00 S$H

Bumbleberry

A triple berry pie made with blueberries, blackberries and raspberries the combination of sweet and tart has made this our most popular fruit pie.

$14.00+ $10.00 S$H

Apple Crumb

A classic pie made with lightly spiced Fuji apples and sweet oatmeal crumb top.

$13.00+ $10.00 S$H

Dark Cherry

Sweet red cherries and a lattice top give this pie the classic look and flavor weve come to expect from cherry pie.

$14.00+ $10.00 S$H

Peach

Made to enhance the natural sweetness and texture of Virginia peaches, this lattice top pie is sure to please.

$13.00+ $10.00 S$H

Speciality Pies

Sweet Potato

A holiday favorite this southern classic pie is wonderful after a big family dinner.

$13.00+ $10.00 S$H

Spiced Pumpkin

Pumpkin puree and just a touch of cream cheese give this pie a fantastic texture and flavor that is sure to please around the holidays or any family occasion.

$13.00+ $10.00 S$H